About Us
Join us
Get in touch
Client portal

Leadership Challenges in AI Implementation

Three years ago, when ChatGPT had only just entered the mainstream, organisations were grappling with a fundamental question: what role would AI play in the future of work?

In our 2023 paper, we argued that the greatest challenge was not the technology itself, but leadership’s ability to provide vision, shape culture, build capability and lead organisational transformation.

Looking back from 2026, that argument has largely been validated. However, the nature of the challenge has evolved in ways few anticipated.

Predictions in 2023

In our 2023 paper, New Leadership Leadership Challenges in AI Implementation, we identified five significant leadership challenges:

  • Developing a clear vision for AI
  • Balancing risk and reward through
  • transformation programmes.
  • Creating a culture capable of embracing
  • Building workforce capability and attracting talent
  • Helping leaders themselves adapt to new ways of working.

At the time, AI was still largely viewed as an emerging technology. Most organisations were experimenting with pilots, testing isolated use cases and attempting to understand the implications for their workforce. The dominant leadership concern was whether AI would be important.

By 2026, that debate is largely over.

The question is no longer whether AI matters. The question is whether organisations can transform quickly enough to capture its value.

The biggest surprise: employees were more ready than leaders

One of the central themes of our 2023 paper was the need for leaders to educate themselves and visibly engage with AI learning. We suggested that leaders might need to “start with themselves” before expecting the wider organisation to change.

Research since then suggests this observation was remarkably prescient.

According to McKinsey’s 2025 workplace research, the biggest obstacle to AI adoption is not employee resistance but leadership hesitation. While almost all organisations are investing in AI, only 1% consider themselves mature in deployment, and McKinsey concluded that “the biggest barrier to success is leadership.”

This represents a reversal of traditional change management assumptions. Historically, leaders worried about workforce resistance to technology. In practice, many employees rapidly adopted generative AI tools, often before organisations had formal strategies in place. The challenge became helping leadership teams keep pace with the workforce.

The uncomfortable reality is that many leaders underestimated both employee readiness and the speed of AI adoption

Culture remains more important than technology

In 2023, we referenced McKinsey research which argued that “technology is not the biggest challenge. Culture is.”

Three years later, that conclusion appears stronger than ever. It is resoundingly what we are hearing from our clients and candidates and is reflected in broader research – In 2025 McKinsey reported that workflow redesign and organisational rewiring are far stronger predictors of AI success than technology deployment itself. Organisations generating meaningful value are redesigning how work gets done rather than simply layering AI onto existing processes. Similarly, BCG’s 2025 research found only 5% of organisations are genuinely “future-built” organisations creating significant value from AI. The difference is not the technology they possess, but their ability to reshape workflows, decision-making processes, talent models and operating structures.

This reinforces an important lesson for leaders:

AI is not fundamentally a technology programme. It is an organisational transformation programme.

Organisations that viewed AI as an IT initiative have generally underperformed those that treated it as a strategic business transformation.

The death of pilot purgatory

Our 2023 paper warned against excessive reliance on isolated AI experiments and cited concerns that organisations could become trapped in low-risk, low-impact initiatives.

This has become one of the defining themes of AI implementation between 2023 and 2026.

Almost nine in ten organisations are now using AI in some form, yet nearly two-thirds remain in experimentation or pilot phases and have not scaled AI across the enterprise. [mckinsey.com],

The phrase “pilot purgatory” has entered mainstream management thinking.

Many organisations successfully demonstrated AI use cases but struggled to integrate them into core business processes. The winners have been those that moved beyond experimentation and embedded AI into critical workflows such as product development, sales, customer service, operations and decision-making processes.

The leadership challenge is no longer identifying use cases, it is scaling them.

The new reality: AI is changing management itself

Perhaps the most significant development since 2023 concerns leadership roles themselves. Our original paper argued that AI might disrupt leadership work as much as anyone else’s. We suggested that leaders could no longer assume technology primarily affected frontline employees.

Recent Harvard Business Review research indicates exactly this is beginning to happen and reflects what we are seeing in the market and hearing from the C-Suite. Use of generative AI show that AI reduces the need for coordination activities traditionally performed by managers. Employees become more autonomous, spend more time on core work and require less project administration. AI is flattening organisational structures and reducing the need for some layers of management.

The implication is profound.

For decades, middle management was largely built around coordinating information, allocating tasks and monitoring progress. AI increasingly performs those functions.

As a result, managerial value is shifting towards:

  • Strategic judgement
  • Coaching and capability development
  • Ethical oversight
  • Change leadership
  • Complex decision-making
  • Building trust and social cohesion

The emergence of the AI value gap

One challenge largely absent from our 2023 paper is now becoming increasingly important: inequality between organisations.

The gap is widening between AI leaders and laggards. A small group of highly mature organisations are generating substantially greater revenue growth, profitability and shareholder returns than their competitors through AI deployment.

The implication for leadership is stark. In previous technology waves, organisations often had years to catch up but with AI, competitive advantages appear to be compounding rapidly.

Governance has become a board level issue

One area where leadership thinking has matured significantly since 2023 is governance.

Early AI discussions focused heavily on capability and innovation but today’s discussions increasingly focus on accountability.

McKinsey’s research highlights that organisations creating significant value from AI are elevating governance responsibilities to CEOs and boards, with senior leadership oversight strongly correlated with superior business outcomes and this reflects growing recognition that AI decisions increasingly touch:

  • Regulatory compliance
  • Intellectual property
  • Data privacy
  • Cybersecurity
  • Brand reputation
  • Ethical decision-making

AI governance is no longer a technical concern, it is a leadership responsibility.

What leadership needs to do in 2026

Looking back, our core message from 2023 remains surprisingly robust. The challenge was never primarily technological, it was always leadership.

What has changed is the speed and scale of the transformation. Three years ago leaders needed vision, communication skills and a willingness to learn. Today they need those capabilities plus the courage to redesign entire operating models, rethink management structures and challenge assumptions that have guided organisations for decades.

The organisations succeeding with AI in 2026 share several characteristics:

  • Leadership teams actively use AI
  • AI is treated as a business transformation initiative rather than a technology
  • Core workflows are redesigned rather than simply
  • Governance is embedded at executive and board
  • Workforce capability building is

Leaders focus on scaling value rather than running isolated pilots.

A final reflection

In 2023, we concluded that leaders would have to become comfortable feeling “nervous, anxious and out of their comfort zone” precisely when their organisations needed confidence and direction.

That observation may be even more relevant today.

The leadership challenge of AI is no longer understanding the technology, it is leading organisations, cultures and people through a transformation whose implications continue to unfold in real time.

The leaders who succeed will not necessarily be the most technically knowledgeable. They will be those capable of creating clarity amid uncertainty, maintaining trust during disruption and reinventing their organisations faster than their competitors.

Three years on, that remains the most important leadership challenge of all.

Read the original thought piece from 2023 here